The Lincoln Homestead by Robert Pettus
Posted: March 18, 2023, 09:44:35 AM
http://www.aphelion-webzine.com/shorts/2023/03/Lincolin.html
I am not a horror fan these days, but there is a problem with this story, in that it violates one of main the rules of horror fiction writing and that is while evil and strong thrive, the very good or the very strong survive. Only the weak are destroyed. Jane does not appear to be weak and there is no reason to think her evil.
A reader wants to get something from a story. It may be a moral, or sentiment, or humor or sadistic pleasure. I got no satisfaction from Jane's fate because she did not appear to deserve it.
I am glad that I read this story even though I did not like it because it helped me clarify my own ideas of what I seek from fiction.
Thank you Robert Pettus.
I am not a horror fan these days, but there is a problem with this story, in that it violates one of main the rules of horror fiction writing and that is while evil and strong thrive, the very good or the very strong survive. Only the weak are destroyed. Jane does not appear to be weak and there is no reason to think her evil.
A reader wants to get something from a story. It may be a moral, or sentiment, or humor or sadistic pleasure. I got no satisfaction from Jane's fate because she did not appear to deserve it.
I am glad that I read this story even though I did not like it because it helped me clarify my own ideas of what I seek from fiction.
Thank you Robert Pettus.